Russian children’s rights ombudsman wants to end foreign adoption

Russian children’s rights ombudsman speaks candidly about his mission to abolish foreign adoption and end Russia’s role as an international “donor of orphans.”

Anna Nemtsova, special to RBTH
February 19, 2013

Russian children’s rights ombudsman Pavel Astakhov, 47, is a man with a controversial mission: to end once and for all the American adoption of Russian children. In an interview with Anna Nemtsova, he said he wants to end foreign adoption entirely. Three years ago, when he was appointed ombudsman for children’s rights, he declared that foreign adoption was “shameful” for Russia. In early February, Astakhov was appointed adviser to the president.

Hot topic: Adoption Ban
Astakhov has had a diverse and storied legal career. In his past work as a defense lawyer, Astakhov frequently criticized the Russian court system. Later he gained more notoriety for being the star judge on a televised legal education show “The Hour of Judgment.”

His international family lives in Moscow and in France; he is married with three sons. His youngest was born in France and his oldest son studied in the United States and United Kingdom. When asked if he would consider adoption, Astakhov said, “That is very difficult; I have no time to see my own children.”

At the time the Russian government decided to ban U.S. adoption at the end of 2012, about 1,000 American families were in the midst of adoption proceedings. The new law was named after Dima Yakovlev, a toddler who died of heat stroke in Virginia, after his adoptive father left him in a parked car for many hours.

More than 60,000 American couples have adopted Russian orphans; 19 of the adopted children have died, some at the hands of their adoptive parents in the United States.

RBTH: One of the main arguments lawmakers made for banning adoption was that it had become impossible to monitor or control Russian orphans once they were in the United States. The owner of a ranch in Montana, Joyce Sterkel, told Kommersant newspaper that if you had asked her properly, she would have received you. Are you aware that she was upset that you referred to her ranch as “a prison for kids”?
P.A.: To be honest with you, I did not read the interview but I can imagine things she said to defend her reputation. A Russian consul visited her ranch in 2010 and saw 30 children including 10 Russian orphans living there. As far as I know, parents paid the ranch owner about $4,000 for every child. (more…)

----------

India’s Orphans FOR EXPORT ONLY?

India’s Orphans
FOR EXPORT ONLY?

by Anant Asthana

Business of selling children in the garb of “Adoption”

goes on and it is hard to dismantle this

adoption-mafia which has come up in India.

Author is a lawyer in Supreme Court of India.
This column is narration of his experiences and views while he is now looking into adoption issue in India.
He can be contacted at anant.asthana@gmail.com

Full text can be read HERE

----------

3-year-old Russian boy killed by American adoptive mother in Texas

Published: 18 February, 2013, 17:57

After being brutally beaten by his American adoptive mother, who gave him psychotropic medication for an extended period of time, a 3-year-old Russian boy named Maksim has died in Texas, Russian diplomats have said.

Russia’s Investigative Committee has launched a probe into the death of Maksim Kuzmin at the hands of his adoptive American family.
The boy died before medics, called by his adoptive mother, arrived at the scene. An autopsy showed that he suffered multiple injuries to his head, limb, abdomen and internal organs prior to death.

The investigation revealed that Maksim was beaten by his adoptive mother, who had also fed him strong psychotropic medication. The boy was given Risperdal, an anti-psychotic drug mainly used for short-term treatment of schizophrenia and bilateral disorders and approved for prescription in the US with the starting age of 10.

The US State Department did not comment on the boy’s death, which reportedly happened on January 21. Nevertheless, the incident became known to the Russian Embassy in the US. (more…)

----------

Argos: rechter Ethiopië verklaart adoptie Nederlands meisje Betty ongeldig

Nieuwsbericht: Ethiopische rechter verklaart adoptie onwettig

Geplaatst op 15 februari 2013       door Barbara Schreuders
Nieuwsbericht Argos (HUMAN, VARA, VPRO)

Een rechtbank in de Ethiopische hoofdstad Addis Ababa heeft deze week de adoptie van een 14-jarig meisje door Nederlandse adoptieouders ongeldig verklaard. Dit meldt het onderzoeksprogramma Argos (Radio 1) vandaag (vrijdag 15 februari 2013) dat het vonnis in handen heeft. Volgens adoptiedeskundigen, die Argos raadpleegde, is zoiets nooit eerder gebeurd. Het meisje, Betty werd in 2005 op 7-jarige leeftijd door een Nederlands echtpaar geadopteerd. Vergunninghouder Wereldkinderen regelde deze adoptie. Betty’s biologische ouders waren op papier dood, terwijl ze nog leven. Zij hebben de rechtszaak aangespannen, onder begeleiding van mensenrechtenorganisatie Against Child Trafficking (ACT).

De biologische ouders wilden Betty weer officieel bij de familie laten inschrijven en haar de achternaam van haar vader teruggeven. Dit kan na de positieve uitspraak van de rechter ook gebeuren. Betty’s adoptie is één van de 19 dossiers die in 2009 in opdracht van Ina Hut, toenmalig directeur van Wereldkinderen, werd onderzocht omdat er sterke aanwijzingen waren van fraude bij Ethiopische adopties. Alle 19 – willekeurig uitgekozen – adoptie-procedures bleken inderdaad niet volgens de regels te zijn verlopen en werden beschreven in het rapport ‘Fruits of Ethiopia’. Argos (VPRO, VARA, HUMAN) berichtte op 6 oktober 2012 in de uitzending: ‘Adoptie, markt van corruptie en geluk’ over misstanden bij adopties in Ethiopië, waaronder die van Betty. Ook het KRO-televisieprogramma Brandpunt berichtte eerder over de zaak van Betty. (more…)

----------

Ethiopian girl had her adoption revoked

Politiken | 14.02.2013 | Page 7

Betty and her mother after the Court hearing.

ADOPTION A Dutch adoption case, which looks like the two Danish cases has ended happily – at least for the girl Betty, who is now her real parents daughter again.

by Dorrit SAIETZ

It could be the girl Masho from the movie ‘adoption come price’ or Amy from Mildura. The story similar to confusion about them: As a 7-year-old Betty Demoze was, with her little sister of 2 years old, adopted by a Dutch couple. But the adoption was based on a bunch of lies: Betty was older than 6 years, what was in the papers, and the children’s parents were not dead.

Like in the two Danish cases things went awry in the adoptive family – Betty missed her real parents and would not give in.

Just as Amy and Masho she was eventually placed outside the adoptive home, but before she managed to spend 2 years in the adoptive family.
Betty’s adoptive parents punished her by beating and kicking her, scolding her and refuse her meals.

At school she did fine, but her teachers had suspicions that all was not as it should be, at home, and eventually got the truth out of her. Her teacher, Louise, ended up becoming her foster mother. (more…)

----------

China: Child Trafficking Sweep Rescues 89

13:06, December 28, 2012

Police in China broke up nine child trafficking rings this week in a sting operation, rescuing 89 children and arresting 355 suspects, the Ministry of Public Security announced Monday.

In the past two and a half years, some 54,000 children have been rescued from traffickers in China, according to government statistics. The children are usually boys, who are sold on the black market and then purchased domestically by families desperate for a male heir.

Chinese media have reported regularly on break up of child-trafficking rings for at least ten years, but the overall numbers are an area of dispute. Security officials tend to report abductions in the range of 30,000 to 60,000, while non-governmental advocates claim the numbers are much greater, as high as 200,000 annually.

Announcing the sweep on Monday, a senior police official said that current prices in the baby trade hover below $5,000 in China’s interior, but that the trafficked children are resold for three times that much in the wealthier coastal provinces, the official Xinhua News Agency reported.

 

----------

Russian President Vladimir Putin signs bill banning Americans from adopting Russian children

Source: http://www.nydailynews.com/news

Putin inks controversial bill less than 24 hours after receiving it from Parliament. Critics wail that the measure turns innocent children into victims for the sole purpose of making a political point. Roughly 740,000 children await adoption in Russia.

BY THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

FRIDAY, DECEMBER 28, 2012, 5:55 AM

Russia’s parliament approves measure to ban Americans from adopting Russian children, in reaction to U.S. human rights legislation: Measure could become law Friday

MOSCOW — President Vladimir Putin on Friday signed a bill banning Americans from adopting Russian children, making the legislation official less than 24 hours after his office received it from Parliament.

The bill has angered Americans and Russians who argue it victimizes children to make a political point, cutting off a route out of frequently dismal orphanages for thousands of children. The Russian-language hashtag “PutinEatsKids” was trending on Twitter just minutes after Putin signed it.

UNICEF estimates that there are about 740,000 children not in parental custody in Russia while about 18,000 Russians are on the waiting list to adopt a child.

The law also blocks dozens of Russian children now in the process of being adopted by American families from leaving the country. The U.S. is the biggest destination for adopted Russian children — more than 60,000 of them have been taken in by Americans over the past two decades.

READ THE FULL TEXT OF THE BILL (more…)

----------

Activists work to stop all adoptions

(INFORMAL TRANSLATION) – published in Danish in Politiken, Denmark, 27 December 2012
Adoption from poor to rich countries creates more orphans than it helps, thinks the NGO Against Child Trafficking.
by Dorrit SAIETZ
One can hardly imagine a more unlikely pair of activists.
Dutch Roelie Post’s former civil servant of the European Commission.
German Arun Dohle is unemployed as financial consultant and an adult adopted child from India.
Their common ‘workplace’ is an unheated basement in a townhouse in Brussels, a few steps from the European Commission flashy glass and steel headquarters.
Here is the NGO Against Child Trafficking based, struggling against adoption. “I thought like everybody else that adoption was good,” says Roelie Post. At least until she in 1999 was asked by her bosses in the EU Commission to take responsibility for solving the problem of Romania’s infamous orphanages.
“Romania could not get in the EU before they respected children and minority human rights,” she says.
The first travel around visiting orphanages and hospitals was a shocking experience. The entire hospital unit was decorated as “baby farm” with rooms where cradles stood in a row. The Romanian minister explained her, laughingly, that he had introduced a points system, so the countries and organisations that contributed the most money, earned points and were then awarded children for adoption. Romania, ten years after the fall of the Wall, had become a huge market for child trafficking. In just ten years, 30,000 children have been adopted by foreign parents who paid large sums of money. (more…)
----------

Colombia has 2nd most adoptions in Latin America

Friday, 17 August 2012 06:50 Courtney Scott

After Haiti, Colombia has the highest amount of adoptions abroad from Latin American countries, reported Caracol Radio Thursday.

Allegedly, 60% of adoptions in Colombia have been sent to parents of other countries.

For congresswoman Angela Maria Robledo, this practice goes against the constitution and various international laws that prioritize children staying with families in their countries of origen. (more…)

----------

NGO Coalition: Social Development Minister arrest revealed unprecedented corruption in issues of international adoption

01/08-2012 08:18, Bishkek – 24.kg news agency , by Julia KOSTENKO

Social Development Minister arrest revealed unprecedented corruption in issues of international adoption. Coalition of Civic Initiatives for Social Security System Reform (NGO Coalition) published official letter on it.

NGO representatives accuse deputies’ intrusion to police work. 24.kg news agency had reported earlier that Social Development Minister Ravshan Sabirov was released in accordance with Bishkek City Court decision after deputies’ guarantees. (more…)

----------